Uss enterprised vs imperial ii star destroyer star trek. Laura broke out her jedi robes and went as a rebel wedding planner. Star trek vessels operate in subspace while at warp, which star wars vessels cannot because they cannot go much faster than light. Trek fluff states that the enterprise shields are impervious to lasers. By contrast, sensors on a star destroyer cannot even detect droids in a unshielded pod.
Captain kirk there is an unknown object coming out of subspace captain kirk. Drug cartels are facing broken supply chains, shrinking revenues. The enterprise would destroy a super star destroyer easily. Find out which ship would come out on top in a oneonone space battle on todays episode of star trek vs star wars. The star wars universe has never even heard of transporter technology, and so wouldnt have any defense against it. In star fleet battles a board game i played boarding parties were one of my best tricks once shields were down. The weapons ranges of the ships are overlaid onto the screen. Star trek has featured a wide variety of combat ranges. Since luke skywalker first looked up at the suns over tatooine in 1977, fans of star wars and star trek have been in a decadeslong debate over which iconic scifi universe is the best. Suppose the star wars empire was centralized in america.
Carriers and fighters are more of a fixture in star wars and babylon 5. With the executors larger size and heavier armor and shields it could just ram the enterprise and destroy it that way. The on screen, gcanon evidence demonstrates that even x wings can circumnavigate gas giants within minutes. Enterprise d vs super star destroyer anandtech forums. So if the enterprise stays at warp speeds it can pretty much attack the star destroyer with impunity. Trek has almost no carriers or fighter squadrons, so id like to see how that would play out in the game. The star trek ships also carry a trump card, which is the transporter. The battle is taking place in a solar system similar to ours. From its very inception in the form of the first 1977 star wars film installment, there has been a definite rivalry between the star wars and star trek franchises, which rod roddenberry son of star trek creator gene roddenberry learned of through firsthand experience, though he was a much bigger fan. Enterprise vs star destroyer fully animated battle star. Stargate bc304 vs enterprise e and star destroyer post by whitelion 20190919 11. Stargate bc304 vs enterprisee and star destroyer page. If you doubt any of these measurements, feel free to take.
This, asuming turbo in this case means rapidfire, would mean that a star destroyer has no hope of damaging starfleet ships. Id actually say star destroyer vs bsg, easy win for the isd every time. Compares the strengths and weaknesses of both franchises, examining them with real science. Imperial star destroyer vs the enterprise d battles comic vine. They cannot track down individual aliens say, wookie on a planet, and most combat occurs at visual range with a remarkable rate of misses. Star destroyer has access to its full compliment of tie fighters. In an onscreen confrontation between archer and the takret captain, archer. Picard claims that the enterprise vs hathaway exercise was the first starfleet battle simulation. Star wars is a science fantasyfiction multimedia franchise created by george lucas. Both ships know that the other is in the system and are separated by 200 au. The enterprise could warp in, fire photon torpedoes, devastate the star destroyer s command center and warp away. Heres the ultimate science fiction size comparison chart. Shipsship of the linestar trek starshipsstar trek beyondsci fi shipsstarship enterprise.
Well, in the sake of universal peace among two very disparate yet similar geek tribes or. Also shown are a soviet typhoon class submarine, the seaquest and the seaview of course, no ship comparison would be complete without comparing the nsea protector nte3120 and the uss. If the enterprise is forced to exit warp, it gets destroyed pretty quickly. The space strategy game galactic civilizations iii now has steam workshop support, and that means its time to settle an old score. Thats not to say that i havent occasionally speculated about the results of crossseries encounters id love to. They agreed they could think of one or two star systems they would have. Rather than waste time proving that the imperial star destroyer can blast kirks enterprise into molten slag, i prefer to enjoy each story based on the merits of its own setting and plot. Uss enterprised vs imperial ii star destroyer star trek vs star. Personally id just ignore the space raptor tm from enterprise and focus on the other media which i believe at least didnt radically change their physiology, while still having a greater degree of agility than was presented on screen. If youve ever done research on star wars vs star trek.
The star destroyer cant see its attacker in warp, even if the enterprise drops out of warp for five seconds two light seconds behind the destroyer it takes time for the empire sensors that move at the speed of light to hit the enterprise and reflect back to the destroyer, lock and swivel the turbo lasers on the target, then two seconds for the beams to reach the spot the enterprise used to be. They deploy fighter and bomber wings by the hundreds, and act like amphibious assault ships with atats, storm troopers, etc. Download broken bow star trek enterprise book 1 pdf free. The site has been inactive for some time, but the forum is still active.
Ships to scale star wars ship size comparisons my note. If the enterprisee from star trek battled an imperial. The enterprise can use its weapons while traveling ftl, the star destroyer cant. In that case, when the enterprise backs up at warp 1. Enterprise wins by showing that discretion is the better part of valour. Also, since you pointed out that the ed can fire weapons while moving ftl, its no contest.
Uss enterprise d vs imperial ii star destroyer star trek topic. A star destroyer could chew up any incarnation of the uss enterprise and spit it out considering the fact that a star destroyer is a lot more heavily armed than most incarnations of the uss enterprise,although the enterprise e may be able to give a star destroyer a run for its money. Larger ships can both outgun and outrun smaller ones. Viewed on the screen of the uss enterprise ncc 1701 from the prime. Despite misgivings, i have agreed to starfleets request that we take part in these wargame exercises. This locks in the size of the executor at eight kilometers long five miles, and for years after that, it. I am a star wars fan, and a star trek fan too, but i would like to point out well youll see. Also, the better shields of a large ship make those light weapons even less effective.
What if a fleet of 10 venatorclass star destroyers arrives on earth, but the star. It says, quite firmly, that the executor is five times the length of a regular star destroyer. A more valid matchup would be a single man unshielded tiefighter vs the enterprise d. I believe later depictions of the gorn books, comics, ent, etc. Joining the enterprise as observer and mediator is the zakdorn master strategist, sirna kolrami. Picard whips past darth vaders ship doing warp 7, popping off photon torpedos at each pass. Could han solo beat captain kirk in a game of dejarik. Broken bow however, the machine malfunctioned a number of times. Broken bow star trek enterprise book 1 download video. Imperial star destroyer vs the enterprise d battles. Could a klingon bird of prey do the kessel run in less than twelve parsecs. For instance, the enterprise vs a group of shuttles or a borg cube vs a federation fleet. This is my interpretation of what a sovergin class starship against a superstar destroyer will be like. Ssds dont go off into space by themselves or any star destroyer, unlike the enterprise.
Is the uss vengeance more powerful than the enterprise e. In this scenario the rob has pitted the enterprise j vs a isd. Youre average imperialclass star destoyer is 1,600 metres long, nearly twice the size of the enterprise e and more than 3 times that speculated for the one fighting here. The first source to attempt to say anything definitive about a star destroyer length is a guide to the star wars universe, written by raymond l. The enterprise j was seen only in the background in the form of graphics on a computer screen. Abrams was gifted a misbegotten screenwriting career by his parents, and so on. The exacutor has been hit by 5 star destroyer going ftl and the shields didnt even go down. A viewscreen or main viewing screen, main screen, or main viewer was an audiovisual device. Find out which ship would come out on top in a oneonone space. Animated the well disputed battle of the tos enterprise vs star destroyer. But its weapons are far too light to deal significant damage to the star destroyer. Stargate bc304 vs enterprise e and star destroyer post by whitelion. The enterprise doesnt even need to beam photon torpedoes onto the destroyer just remove any one of the million things the destroyer needs to prevent itself from exploding and youre done. The enterprise e should be the far superior ship, but conceptually and on screen it is very dated with its standard sweeping phaser and torpedo combination.
A force of four of the massive kazon battleships, larger and more voluminous than a star destroyer, attempt to snare voyager in a trap. As far as taking a beating, the galactica took a nuke hit. Birth of the federation no specific history or definitive final fate was established for this vessel as its name was selected for a cruiser by the game developers, and is placed randomly when the ship appears. According to rob bonchune, from what i understand, it was done quick and dirty, so was not really detailed in any way like a model we would use in multiple shots. Enterprise has a speed advantage, and i dont know if this is correct, but ive never seen laserfire coming from the back of a star destroyer, so that seems like a huge weakness. The enterprise is a lot more maneuverable that a star destroyer. And since the exacutor is faster 1,200 g vs 1,000 g then the enterprise is. Weve ranked 40 iconic star trek ships, probes and shuttles from the relatively.
The enterprise has an incredible range advantage, fighting battle at. The executor could take on the entire federation fleet without losing shields, or really taking any damage at all. And no, enterprise wouldnt change planet surface into glass. The uss crusader was a federation galaxy xclass heavy cruiser starship in starfleet service in the 24th century. Darth maul came back to life because disney would rather drive pandas to extinction than let a marketable villain go to waste, emperor palpatine came back to life because j. Excellent work, but must take issue with the size of the borg ship compared to the trade federation command ship.
358 1005 34 1203 759 756 1353 871 306 59 1083 550 750 613 348 618 950 1285 472 1028 1360 527 1559 1431 658 1289 1151 887 747 1318